Immigration Reform: Where the Blame Really Lies

There is much disappointment over President Obama’s decision to delay promised administrative changes to immigration policy until after November’s mid-term election. Millions of undocumented workers will continue to live in the shadows, farms and businesses that depend on immigrant labor will face ongoing uncertainty about the availability of labor, and young people brought here as children still won’t know whether they will be able to stay to work and raise families (and pay taxes) over the long term.

Still, the President had a point. Anything he might attempted by way of common sense reform at this point would have fired up the Tea Party, already crying for impeachment, and might have cost the Democrats the Senate.  If that happened, politicians would have been afraid to go near the issue for years to come.

Before we blame President Obama for the absence of immigration reform, let’s ask where the blame really lies. The answer is clear: it lies with the Republican-controlled House of Representatives, where New York’s 23rd is represented by Republican Tom Reed.

The Senate passed a major immigration reform bill, S. 744, in June 2013. The bill was resulted from legislators doing what they ought to do: hammer out compromises to deal with the problems that face the nation. It would commit additional resources to border security, while creating a “tough but fair” legalization process for those who are already here. It incorporates the DREAM Act, and would make it easier for highly skilled individuals, educated in the United States, to remain.

If Speaker Boehner had allowed this bill to come before the House, it would almost certainly have passed with the support nearly all Democrats and some Republicans. But ever anxious to appease the Tea Party, Boehner refused to permit a vote.

Does immigration reform matter to New York’s 23rd? Martha Robertson, who is challenging Reed, has traveled the district tirelessly and reports that Red Jacket Orchards’ strawberry crop has plummeted 75 per cent over the past two years due to a labor shortage. Vineyard owners never know if they are going to be able to find enough workers to keep the vines trimmed, and other farmers face labor shortages and labor uncertainty as well. S. 744 would create a “blue card” for undocumented agricultural workers who have worked at least 100 days over a two-year period, allowing them to remain. This provision would give both workers and farmers much-needed assurance of workforce stability.

Cornell and other colleges and universities in or near the district graduate many foreign students every year who are highly qualified in science, technology, engineering, and medicine. Imagine how much the district would benefit if these productive young people were able to remain. The president of the University of Massachusetts maintains that they should have green cards stapled to their diplomas, but this won’t happen without immigration reform.

Immigration reform would be good for our district’s economy and good for the economy of the nation. That’s one more reason to help turn the Republicans out of the House by voting for Martha Robertson on November 4.









This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Immigration Reform: Where the Blame Really Lies

  1. Deb Meeker says:

    It’s hard to believe with all his many touted visits to farmers in Ny 23rd, that Rep Reed wasn’t told how his leadership’s obstruction has hurt their businesses. Did farmers tell Reed, and he just didn’t listen? Or, did Reed tell them what he thinks they should do about the shortage of workers, out his vast farming experience?


  2. BOB McGILL says:‎CachedSimilar
    Aug 30, 2012 … According to the Farm Labor Shortage Mythologists, American citizens are just
    too lazy and would rather go jobless than work on a farm. … Georgia was going to
    have a “rancid harvest” due to its farm labor shortage, according …


  3. BOB McGILL says:

    you gotta read this !!!!!!! 🙂‎CachedSimilar
    willing to do agricultural work and increasing wages to attract native-born
    workers … Over the same period, the average real wage of …. While there is no
    evidence of a nationwide labor shortage, businesses ….. citizens to volunteer to
    take up agricultural jobs and highlights the lack of response so far as evidence
    that few,.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.